Jamie Whiffen

Why Your Subscribers Aren't Watching Your New Videos

2026-11-11
-
0
min read
GrowVeg's video The Clever Way Gardeners Make Soil from Leaves, over 390,000 views

50,000 Subscribers and 450 Views a Video

Hey,

Last week I got on a call with a team whose channel has nearly 50,000 subscribers.

Their recent videos average about 450 views.

And the channel hasn't made them a penny. In their words, "we are literally paying for it."

Here's how it happened. They grew it fast with paid ads, and the ads did exactly what they were paid to do, which was get people to press subscribe.

But a subscriber is just someone who pressed a button once. Most of the people who pressed it never came back.

And YouTube doesn't show your new video to everyone who subscribed. It shows it to the people who actually watch you, and then watches how they respond. So their subscriber number kept climbing while the views stayed flat.

It's like a gym that sells a thousand memberships to people who never come in. The number on the sign looks great, and the gym is empty.

You don't need ads for this to happen to you either. One video takes off, thousands of people subscribe for that one topic, and most of them never watch the next one.

So what should you actually watch instead? Here are the three things I told that team to track.

1. Regular viewers

Open YouTube Studio, click Analytics, then the Audience tab. You'll see your viewers split into new, casual and regular. Regular viewers are the people who keep coming back.

That's your real audience. They're the ones who watch the next video, trust what you say and eventually buy from you.

One of my clients, a financial planner, had regular viewers at 7% of his monthly audience when we looked last week. I'd want that nearer 12 to 15%, so that's the number we're working on, and his subscriber count barely comes up.

2. Casual viewers you win back

Even huge channels live off people coming back. I work with GrowVeg, a gardening channel with over 1.1 million subscribers, and last week I told the team to expect only 7 to 15% of their viewers to be brand new from now on, because most people in their market have already seen one of their videos.

So their growth comes from winning casual viewers back with the next great idea, and that's where we put the effort.

3. A tracked link on every video

Put a link in every description that's unique to that video. A link shortener works fine, just make a new short link for each video so the clicks are counted separately.

Then you can see which videos actually send people to whatever you sell, whether that's a course checkout, your community or a call booking page. Your subscriber count will never tell you that.

Subscribers tell you how many people once liked one of your videos. Regular viewers tell you how many people would notice if you stopped posting, and they're the ones who pay you.

Open Studio today, find your regular viewers for the last 28 days and write the number down. That's the number to grow.

Jamie

P.S. If you want to work with me on growing the audience that comes back and buys, rather than a number that just looks good, book a call here and we'll see if we're a fit.

Start Getting Views

Put these ideas into practice.

Get The Million-View Blueprint, my free five-day email course to help you make better YouTube videos.

You can read all my previous newsletters here →